Goodbye Sandra Day, Hello Sam Alito
Tuesday, January 31st, 2006Today, the Senate voted 58-42 to confirm Judge Samuel Alito to the United States Supreme Court. Shortly thereafter, Judge Alito was sworn in as Justice Alito by CJ Roberts. I heartily congratulate Justice Alito and wish him many years of originalist interpretation on the Court.
Alito’s ascension to the Court means that Justice Sandra Day O’Connor has written her last opinion. Thankfully so. With one more Bush nomination to the Supreme Court (assuming he nominates a true, verifiable conservative jurist), the Court will be able to forestall any judicial foray into the activist realms of foreign policy, legislative policy, and the rights of State governments to determine what social mores govern their peculiar populaces.
Alito’s confirmation illustrates the importance of having a Republican Senate. Alito was able to sway only three Democrats to his side–he lost the liberal Republican Lincoln Chafee’s vote. Without the Senate, President Bush’s insistence on nominating a judge in the likeness of Scalia or Thomas might not have been possible. Also, the Alito confirmation process illustrates the profundity of the Democrats lackluster and highly irascible objections to Alito. The Democrats, in order to thwart Alito’s nomination, needed to persuade a modest amount of Republicans to jump ship. To do this, they either would have needed to fester a concern among true conservative Republicans that Alito is a liberal on social issues and would vote based upon his personal policy preferences or convinced some of the “moderate” Republicans (particularly Specter) that Alito was the second coming of Robert Bork. The Democrats accomplished neither, being more concerned about boosting their campaign contribution amounts for ‘06 and placating their Hard Left base, resulting in a disorganized, smattering of objection whose effect was a mere whisper on those Senators whom the Dems needed in their anti-Alito voting bloc.
Justice Alitoanother victory for President Bush and another indicator of the detectable Democratic Party malaise. Hurrah!